A few years ago, the cyber insurance application was something an office manager could fill out in twenty minutes. Check yes to a few questions about firewalls and backups, sign at the bottom, get the policy. Most carriers were still learning what they were covering.

That era ended. As claims costs climbed and the incidents behind them became easier to trace back to specific security failures, carriers changed their approach. The questions got more specific. The answers started to matter. And in a growing number of renewals, carriers are now asking IT providers to attest to the controls on your behalf or sending auditors to verify what you said.

If you are renewing a policy or applying for one for the first time, the controls below are what most carriers now require. Not request. Require.

$21B
US internet crime losses in 2025, up from $16B the year before — FBI Internet Crime Report
58%
of all cyber insurance claims involve email fraud and funds transfer fraud — Coalition 2026 Claims Report
10–20%
of small and midsize businesses actually carry cyber insurance — Swiss Re, 2026
48%
of 2025 data breaches involved ransomware — Verizon 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report

Multi-Factor Authentication

MFA is the control that comes up most on carrier applications, and it is also where the most misunderstandings happen. Having MFA on your Microsoft 365 email is a good start, but when a carrier asks whether you have MFA enforced, they mean across all of the following: email, VPN, remote desktop access, cloud applications, and administrator accounts.

Administrator accounts deserve their own note. Many small businesses have one or two IT admin accounts that were set up years ago and never had MFA applied because it was inconvenient. Those accounts are exactly what attackers target. A ransomware group does not need to trick your entire staff. They need one admin credential without a second factor, and they have the run of your systems.

Before your next renewal, check whether MFA is required for every access method into your network, not just the ones your team uses every day.

Endpoint Detection and Response

Carriers have largely stopped accepting Windows Defender or basic antivirus as a sufficient answer to the endpoint protection question. What they are looking for now is endpoint detection and response, usually shortened to EDR, or managed detection and response, which is EDR with a team monitoring it.

The difference matters. Standard antivirus checks files against a list of known threats and blocks the ones it recognizes. EDR watches what software is actually doing on a machine and flags behavior that looks like an attack, even if the specific malware has never been seen before. That behavioral layer is what most modern attacks are designed to bypass on traditional antivirus.

If your IT company manages endpoint protection for you, ask directly what platform you are running and whether it qualifies as EDR. If you are not sure, that answer needs to change before your renewal conversation with your broker.

Backups That Have Actually Been Tested

Most businesses with a backup problem do not find out until they try to restore from one. The carrier application does not just ask whether you have backups. It asks whether they are offsite or in the cloud, whether backup credentials are separate from your main network credentials, whether backups are immutable or protected from deletion, and whether you have tested a restore.

That last point is where many businesses fall short. A backup that has never been tested is a backup whose reliability is unknown. Carriers know this. Some now ask for documentation of the last successful recovery test, and a few require it quarterly.

Backups that are accessible from the same credentials as your main environment are also a problem. Ransomware routinely deletes or encrypts backups before deploying its payload. If your backup drive is mapped to a network share that an infected machine can reach, it is not a meaningful backup for purposes of recovery or insurance.

An Incident Response Plan

Carriers want to see a written plan that describes what your business does when something goes wrong. Not necessarily a complex document, but one that answers the basics: who gets called, in what order, what systems get taken offline, who handles communication with customers, and when legal counsel is involved.

This matters both for the application and for a claim. Most cyber insurance policies require timely notification of a breach, often within 48 to 72 hours of discovery. Organizations without a defined process frequently miss that window, not because they were hiding something but because no one had thought through the steps in advance.

A one-page response checklist that your team has reviewed once is better than nothing. A tested plan that assigns specific roles is better still.

Patching and Vulnerability Management

Outdated software is one of the most common factors in successful attacks, and it is one of the cleaner things carriers can audit. They look for whether operating systems are current, whether critical patches are applied within a defined window, and whether any legacy systems still running software past end of support are isolated from the main network.

If you are still running Windows 10 machines in your environment, that is a conversation worth having before renewal, not after. End-of-support systems do not automatically disqualify you from coverage, but they do require documentation of compensating controls, and some carriers will exclude incidents originating from them.

Why the Answers on the Application Actually Matter

When a claim is filed, the carrier reviews the application you submitted. If you answered yes to having MFA on all remote access and the investigation shows that was not accurate when the incident occurred, the carrier can deny the claim on grounds of material misrepresentation. That is not a technicality. It is a standard contract term, and it applies whether the inaccuracy was intentional or just a question you answered without fully checking.

This is the part of the conversation that tends to get uncomfortable. Business owners sometimes check yes to controls their IT provider installed years ago without confirming what is actually active today. Things change. A VPN upgrade that removed MFA enforcement. A backup job that stopped running six months ago. A security tool that was replaced and not like-for-like.

The time to reconcile those discrepancies is before a renewal, not while you are waiting to hear whether a breach claim will be paid.

Before your next renewal: Ask your IT provider to walk through the carrier application questions with you and attest to which controls are actively in place. If there are gaps, you have time to close them. If there are controls listed that are not actually running, correct the application. A claim denied for misrepresentation is worse than a premium that reflects the actual risk.

How Next Level Computers Can Help

We work with small businesses across metro Atlanta that are going through cyber insurance renewals, and we see the application questions get more specific every year. We can review what you currently have in place, help you document controls accurately, and address gaps before they become problems at renewal or at claim time.

If you are unsure where your current setup stands relative to what carriers are asking for, reach out to us or see what services we offer. We are based in Suwanee and have worked with businesses across Gwinnett, Forsyth, and surrounding counties since 2005.

Sources

  1. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) Internet Crime Report 2025, as cited in Insurance Journal, October 2026
  2. Coalition 2026 Cyber Claims Report
  3. Swiss Re market penetration estimate, as cited in Insurance Journal, October 2026
  4. Verizon 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report, as cited in Insurance Journal, October 2026